Reading preferences are so strange. Even among avid readers and writers, the same book can evoke totally different reactions. Sometimes one person will enjoy a book and another person will hate it.
I've also seen a lot of times lately where one person will think a book is absolutely horribly written and another person thinks it's the cat's meow. Those aren't the same thing: I can dislike a book while admitting that it's well done but just not my cup of tea. Yet it's odd how often people can disagree on even whether something is well-crafted, aside from whether they liked it.
Not long ago, a good friend of mine despised two books I really enjoyed (one of which I loved and read in one sitting, which is very rare for me).
Another friend said that an author I enjoy is too much like Jane Austen . . . like that's a bad thing.
And yet another friend recommended a book that nearly seared my eyeballs it was so bad. I couldn't finish it.
At the core, I suppose, is the fact that there are few hard and fast rules when it comes to writing. While not everything is subjective in this gig, a lot is. Where I can't stand Faulkner or Hemingway, I do like Steinbeck, but I know others who feel exactly the opposite.
I'm a pretty eclectic reader. I don't focus on a single genre, and the titles I pick up are all over the map, so in general, I think I have a pretty decent idea when something is "good."
Which is probably reflective in a conversation I had tonight with my husband:
Me: "Hey, you know that book I'm reading?"
DH gives me a blank look. He pretends to count books on the fingers of both hands, then looks up and grins.
And I about fall over laughing at myself.
So yeah, okay, that was a stupid question. A really stupid one. I needed to be a bit more specific, being as at any given time I'm reading half a dozen (or several more) books.
"Hey, honey, you know that hardback novel I'm reading that's about this thick and has a blue cover with white text? The one I was reading this afternoon while you sat by me watching Monk?"
Or maybe I should be a normal person and read one book at a time.
(Stop laughing. It could happen. Maybe. Okay, fine.)
In all seriousness, what do you think completes this sentence, at least for you:
A good book . . .
I thought I had a lot of the answers, but seeing so many titles I love being trashed by others (and the flip: books I really, really dislike heralded as brilliance), I'm not so sure anymore.
Prime Day Deals! Golden Valley Romance series, by Liz Isaacson Eight cowboys and the women who can keep them warm in the snowy Mont...
First off, don't miss the two giveaways hosted by I Am a Reader: Here's the $100 giveaway . And here's the $25 giveaway on ...
I touched on this recently on Facebook, but because the horse isn't fully dead yet, here's a more thorough another beating: The te...
Below are the links & information from today's newsletter. To hear the news first, SUBSCRIBE . ORIENT EXPRESS Launch Party W...